The Battle of Gilford - 1772
D. E. McElroy
On the afternoon of the 6th March 1772 a force of two thousand Hearts of Steel, many of them armed with guns, attacked Gilford Castle, the home of Richard Johnston. The castle was defended by a militia of Johnston's friends, neighbours and tenants and the defenders held off the attack for over an hour before the attackers forced an entry and overran the castle.
Who were the Hearts of Steel and why did they feel such a fury against their local landlord and magistrate?
The Hearts of Steel
The 1760s in the north of Ireland had brought about severe discontent among small tenant farmers due to a succession of bad harvests and impositions by the ruling class through demands for tithes, labour on the roads and higher rents. Events were brought to a head by Lord Donegall's need for ready cash to finance the large Palladian mansion which he was building in Staffordshire. Tenants were prepared for a rise in rents when their leases became due for renewal but such increases would not bring in extra revenue quickly enough for Donegall's need. He, instead, demanded a heavy fine to be paid for the renewal of the lease. Tenants, who often lived on a subsistence basis, could not find immediate cash and so the fine was often paid by speculators who thus acquired the leases. They then relet the farms to landless peasants who were so desperate for land that they were willing to pay exorbitant sums.
On Donegall's estates in South Antrim, tenants who were faced with dispossession formed a secret society to resist forcibly the new policy. Within months this society had spread through Antrim, Down and Armagh. This rapid growth testifies to the very real sense of injustice felt by the tenants. The following contemporary verse speaks of their motives:
Some of the tenants still remain that feel
Their wrongs and can resist with Hearts of Steel,
Bravely resolved in mutual league unite
To keep possession and support their right.
The tactics of the Hearts of Steel (or Steelboys) were those of intimidation - intimidation of landlords, speculators and those who would have paid the higher rent. This intimidation took the form of threats of personal violence, the burning of houses and barns and the houghing (maiming by the cutting of hamstrings) of cattle.
Many of the Steelboys were Presbyterian but by no means all of the Presbyterian community was involved in the movement. All over the North Eastern counties congregations published lists of those who were opposed to the movement and also published the names of those who refused to subscribe their signature to the list! One may suspect, there-fore, that many of those whose names appeared in the notices of disassociation with the movement in the Belfast News-letter in 1771 and 1772 may have been secret sympathisers. It is noteworthy that juries were unwilling to convict Steelboys and this was often due to sympathy with their cause rather than a fear of the consequences. The following notice inserted in the Newsletter by the Presbytery of Dromore is indicative of the feelings of the more sober elements of society.
"A Serious Warning and Admonition"
With the utmost concern we have of late observed in our bounds a dissolute and licentious spirit productive of numberless disorders. With grief we find that many persons:
- riotously associate
- travel from house to house
- extort arms and ammunition by the most dreadful threats from peaceable inhabitants
- administer unlawful oaths
- burn and otherwise destroy houses
- compel men to sign leases at what valuations they please and assume to themselves the power of courts of justice consulting and decreeing in all causes referred to the, and putting their determinations in force by the most violent means.
We entreat you for God's sake, for Christ's sake, turn not your liberty any longer into such licentiousness. Enter not into the council of the ungodly; and may the God of peace bring order out of confusion."
Richard Johnston had come in to ownership of the Gilford estate on the death of his father in 1758. The estate had been founded by Captain John Magill in the 1660s when he was given leases for the creation of a small village beside an important ford in the River Bann. The village took Magill's name and was known first as Magill's Ford, then Gillford and eventually Gilford. The Magill family soon died out on the male side and passed to the Johnstons on the distaff side.
Richard Johnston was descended from the Johnstons of Annandale in Scotland, famous border reivers whose motto was Nunquam Non Paratus - Never Unprepared, a motto which he lived by in a convincing manner. He was described by his contemporaries as energetic, zealous and implacable; epithets which were well deserved in his relationships with the Hearts of Steel.
As a magistrate he was most unwilling to tolerate the development of the Steelboy movement in the Gilford district; this antipathy resulting in him being the recipient of a number of threatening letters from the movement.
In a characteristically energetic response to these letters he formed a local defence force or militia comprised of his friends, neighbours and tenants. There were about fifty members in this force and an ex-army sergeant, Alexander Adamson, was employed to train them so that they would be able to resist any attack by the insurgents. This training began on 24th February 1772 and along with the other recruits was one somewhat unlikely member - the Rev Samuel Morrell (Morrel, Morrel or Morelle), Presbyterian minister of Tully-lish, three miles from Gilford.
Rev Samuel Morrell
The Rev Samuel Morrell had been called to Tullylish on 6th March 1768 at the young age of twenty-four. He was, almost certainly, a member of the famous Huguenot Morrell family whose history is chronicled in Samuel Smiles' book on the Huguenots.
When he came to Tullylish he showed an extreme dislike both for the Hearts of Steel and also for the popular superstitions of the area. This dislike was demonstrated by his membership of Johnston's militia on the one hand and by his actions in cutting down the blossom of the hawthorn on the other. While the more affluent members of the Presbyterian community were opposed to the Hearts of Steel, his action in joining an armed force against them was seen, even at the time, as somewhat extreme. An explanation may lie in his friendship with Richard Johnston, which seems to have been a close and genuine relationship and also in the desire on the part of the Huguenots - after having been opposed to the state in France for generations - to become part of the British established order.
The Battle of Gilford
On March 2nd 1772 a group of eight hundred Hearts of Steel demonstrated in Gilford by marching up and down the village street, under the windows of the castle. After a time they disbanded and went home peacefully and without having caused any damage. This challenge to his authority, however, enraged the implacable Mr Johnston.
When Morrell informed him on March 5th that the leading deputies of the Hearts of Steel were meeting at the house of one Tidderton in the townland of the Clare, Johnston determined on immediate action. Accompanied by Morrell, Sgt Adamson and a man named Thomas Logan he went immediately to Tidderton's house, where the Steelboy leaders were having a meal of herrings and potatoes. When Johnston's band burst in they found their victims seated round the table on which there were piles of coin as well as food. It was later alleged that this money had been collected to buy ball and shot. Morrell and Adamson took two prisoners named Hill and Dennison while Johnston and Logan also took two prisoners one of whom was called Finlay. Finlay soon managed to escape but the other three were brought as prisoners to Gilford from whence they were sent the next morning under strong escort to Downpatrick.
Finlay, on his escape, lost no time in arousing the neighbour-hood and in this he was assisted by Hill's father. Horns were blown throughout the area as a sign for a general uprising and help was requested from the Hearts of Steel in Lurgan and Portadown. On the next day, Friday March 6th columns of Steelboys from the Gilford area, Lurgan and Portadown converged on Gilford. The Lurgan contingent was led by Richard Savage and the Portadown men by William (Billy) Redmond. Contemporary writers remarked on the military discipline of the insurgents and this was largely due to the number of ex-soldiers among their leaders, Savage for example having been a sergeant in the army.
Various estimates have been given of the size of the rescue force, these varying between one and two thousand men. Majority opinion seemed to favour the higher number.
This shows both the strength of the organisation in the area at the time and also the depth of feeling caused by Johnston's action in arresting the three. It was claimed that Hill's father had threatened to kill both Morrell and Johnston and also to cut Johnston's body into quarters and display them on the corners of his castle.
By noon on 6th March the rescuers had congregated in Gilford bringing with them guns, powder and ball, horns and bugles and, interestingly, fire in pitchers for the purpose of burning down the castle. On arrival in the village their fury was increased by the discovery that the prisoners were no longer there. By his speedy action Johnston had, however, weakened his defences by sending a large number of his armed militia as an escort for the prisoners. On the afternoon of March 6th he had twenty-three armed men in the castle but there was only enough powder and shot for each defender to be given ten rounds. These men were placed at the windows of the castle and prepared to resist the insurgents.
Mr Johnston then leaned out of one of the parlour windows with a blunderbuss on his arm and called out to those on the street outside, asking that they send two or three representatives to speak with him. The reply to this was a volley of shots none of which hit him. Soon a full-blooded gun fight began between the Hearts of Steel and the defenders of the castle. The assailants broke down the demesne wall and set fire to the gardener's house, destroying it. Fire was kept up on the gable wall, Johnston being wounded slightly in the head. Much more seriously, Samuel Morrell, who appears to have taken a leading part in the defence, was shot first in the arm and then in the left breast. After the second wound he ran up the stairs, probably in shock, and jumped out of a two pair of stairs window. Such was the rage of the attackers that they continued to fire at his body which received many wounds.
After several fruitless attempts at sending out a flag of truce, first held by his steward and then by himself, Johnston resolved to make a break. He jumped over a wall, swam across a mill race which ran beside his house, ran across his lawns and swam across the Bann, being fired at all the time with the bullets flying about him in the water. On reaching the other side of the Bann he was so exhausted that he could not climb the steep bank. Luckily for him a sympathetic girl called Davidson helped him out of the water, up the bank and brought him to a cabin. He mounted a horse and rode bareback to Newry to obtain help from the military garrison.
After The Battle
With their leader's escape or desertion (there are two opinions on this though it is difficult to see what other option he had) the remaining garrison quickly surrendered, the fight having lasted for half an hour. At first it looked as if things might go badly for them. Thomas Logan afterwards gave evidence that both he and his father were dragged out by the assailants who debated whether to shoot him or throw him on the fire. At length they released him on his promise to take their oath and join their society. Other defenders seem to have got off lightly, the attackers desire for revenge having been satisfied by the death of Morrell and the flight of Johnston.
They did destroy the interior of the house and cut down the fine trees in the demense but the discovery of a large quantity of wine in the cellars distracted their attention. William Redmond formed the Portadown men into a military formation and ordered them to march home by the shortest way possible. He obviously did not want a general rampage to develop, especially as drink had been taken.
On Sunday March 8th Johnston returned to Gilford with a company of soldiers to find his house ransacked, the interior destroyed and his plantations cut down. He was later to estimate the damage done at £2,200 exclusive of the estate improvements destroyed and the title deeds and other papers lost.
For the Steelboys the victory at Gilford proved to be a Pyrrhic one as it provoked a heavy military repression in the whole area. A panic spread because of the possibility of reprisals and one newspaper reported that in the Gilford district in the closing days of March there was scarcely a man to be seen other than those wearing red coats. Johnston, who was incensed by the death of his friend Morrell and the destruction of his property, immediately began to hunt down the ringleaders with great energy. This is shown by the following extract from the Belfast News-letter:
"We hear that Mr Johnston of Gilford having received information that one Redmond, being a leader of the Hearts of Steel, was lurking in the vicinity of Monterevlin in the county of Tyrone. He, with a party of light horse, set out from Gilford to apprehend him and arriving at midnight at the house where he lodged (30 miles from Gilford) and being refused admission ... Johnston entered with the party at his back where Redmond lay. He started up and having a charged pistol at his side snapped it at Mr Johnston's head which burnt priming whereupon one of the military party discharged his pistol and wounded Redmond in the side of which he is since dead.''
The account of Redmond's death does however seem to be somewhat exaggerated as he appeared a short time later as a defendant at the trials in Dublin!
There was considerable sympathy on the part of the Government in Dublin for Richard Johnston, evidence of this being the grant of a pension of £400 a year to him. He was not satisfied with this and on petition soon had it raised to £800. On 27th July 1772 he was created a Baronet and later became a member of the Irish Parliament.
This was held in Dublin, beginning on Wednesday August 12th 1772 against a background of public discontent. The decision to hold the trial in Dublin was a consequence of the difficulty of securing a conviction in the north but the residents of Co Dublin saw this as a serious infringement of civil liberties. There were references to Magna Carta and Habeas Corpus and there was a general feeling that poor men could not have a fair trial so far from their homes as they could not afford to bring defence witnesses to speak on their behalf.
The accused were:
- John Byrns - Murder of Rev Samuel Morrell.
- William Redmond - Leading, Commanding and Disciplining Insurgents.
- Philip McCusker - Bringing fire in a pitcher. Destroying silver knives.
- James Fryers - Blowing a horn.
- John Hill - Threatening Mr Johnston's life.
- Moses Evans - Firing two shots.
- Michael Corr - Being armed.
- James Davison - Being armed.
- George Foster - Plundering Mr Johnston's house.
The trial was conducted by nine commissioners under Lord Annally. All through the proceedings it was apparent that there was a degree of sympathy for the defendants. In his closing address Lord Annally exhorted the jury that if they were not thoroughly convinced in their consciences of the guilt of any or all of the prisoners they should lean on the side of mercy remembering the maxim ''that it is better ten guilty persons should escape than one innocent person be condemned". The jury took him at his word and after an absence of only seventeen minutes brought in a verdict of not guilty.
Sir Richard did not easily give up his desire for revenge and this was especially so in the case of Billy Redmond. After the Dublin trial the Armagh magistrates indicted him again on other charges but the Armagh petty jurors imitated their Dublin counter-parts and found him not guilty. The furious gentlemen of the Grand Jury still wanted him transported on some pretext but the judges would not agree to this and had him entirely cleared.
The three original prisoners who had been sent to Downpatrick were soon released without charge. The Hearts of Steel had been like a blaze of whins. They convulsed three counties for a few years and disappeared just as quickly. This was in part due to a massive emigration of tenant farmers to the Carolinas in America. Many of these were almost immediately involved in the American War of Independence, the cause of the revolutionaries having much sympathy in Ulster. The saddest part of the whole story is the fate of Samuel Morrell. That there was a real bond of friendship between himself and Sir Richard Johnston is evident from the touching memorial that Sir Richard had erected in his memory in Tullylish Presbyterian Church. Others, however, took a cooler view. One contemporary account included the words - "However unbecoming it was in him to fight with the arm of flesh - especially his own flock".
The superstitious regarded their beliefs as having been confirmed. They remembered his assault on the fairy thorns and shortly after his death some remarkably fine verses circulated in the area attributing his fate to the Queen of the Fairies.
Today little is remembered of the Battle of Gilford and the Hearts of Steel. Yet one has only to look at the papers of 1772 to realise the impact that the events made on Irish opinion at the time.
Rather than praise or blame any of the participants it may be wiser to conclude that they were creatures of their time as we are of ours and that they acted as they saw right according to their beliefs.
Verses concerning the death of Rev Samuel Morrell which circulated in the Gilford area shortly after the event.
The moon shone down
with a glancing beam
On valley and wood by Banna's stream,
Whilst the Fairy Queen with her Elfin train
Made the wild woods ring with unhallow'd strain,
"Woe to him who with sneering word
The wrath of the Elfin race hath stirred,
Who hath dared to mock the mystic power
They long have swayed o'er rath and bower.
For an early tomb and an evil doom
Shall wait in his path like the tiger grim
To snatch his life in his hour of bloom,
And none at his bier shall weep for him."
The old and the wise have warned in vain,
For his shirt is red with the bloody stain
And tomorrow's sun ere it leave the sky
Shall see his corpse on the cold earth lie
For his hand hath torn the fairy thorn,
And flung on the earth its fragrant bloom,
And the Fair Queen for his deeds of scorn
Hath damned his life with a fatal doom.
And when by the stream the children play
They shall hush their glee as they pass this way,
And none shall pluck from the fairy ring
The flowers that forth from the green leaves spring.
For the old shall tell the fate of Morrell,
And the woeful fate of the hawthorn spray,
And warn the child of its mystic spell,
And the Queen of the Fairies potent sway.
The sun shone down with a joyous beam
On valley and wood by Banna's stream,
And their depths re-echoed the sounding horn
And its notes were borne on the breeze of the morn;
Whilst the sentinel cried at Johnston's home,
"’Tis the 'Hearts of Oak', they come - they come."
The proud Sir Richard had mocked their power,
And dared their might in an evil hour,
But turret and tower were armed in vain
For the oakmen came like the foaming main,
When its breast is torn by the howling blast,
And its angry waves roll fierce and fast.
But a form was seen on the Castle wall,
And a prayer for mercy was heard by all,
But alas! no prayer could then assuage
The savage flame of the rebel rage.
For ah! from the Castle the young Morrell
Who had sued for mercy, lifeless fell.
The fairies laughed with unearthly glee
As they danced that night round the fatal tree,
And they twined in its shade a wreath of flowers,
To deck the Queen of their Elfin bowers.
- James S Donnelly : Hearts of Oak - Hearts of Steel - Studio Hibernica 21 (1981) pp 7-31.
- W A Maguire : Lord Donegall and the Hearts of Steel - Irish Historical Studies XXI 84 Sept. 1979 pp 351-76.
- Dean Myles : The Parish of Tullylish - Lib. H.Q. Armagh.
- Dean Orr : The Village of Gilford (papers) - Lib. H.Q. Armagh.
- Belfast Newsletter (1772 - Lib. H.Q. Armagh.
- Kieran Clendinning : A General Study of Waringstown.
Our thanks to D. E. McElroy for this article.